Is a child in immediate danger? Call 911.Find help & reporting lines →
Research & Insights

APSAC's Position Statement on Corporal Punishment of Children

About this page: An earlier website at this address once shared APSAC's position statement on this page. That site is no longer active; this independent summary replaces it and links to APSAC's official statement.

Key takeaways

  • APSAC, a national society of professionals who work with maltreated children, approved its position statement on corporal punishment on July 26, 2016.
  • It calls for eliminating all forms of corporal punishment and physical discipline of children in every setting, including homes and schools.
  • Its main reasons: corporal punishment raises the risk of physical abuse and is linked to aggression and antisocial behavior, with no studies showing benefits.
  • It asks professionals to educate families about the harms, about age-appropriate expectations, and about positive, non-physical discipline.

The American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children (APSAC) is a national organization for professionals who serve children and families affected by maltreatment — pediatricians, social workers, therapists, investigators, attorneys and researchers. In 2016 it adopted a position statement calling for an end to all corporal punishment of children. Because the statement is frequently cited in debates about spanking and school paddling, this page explains what it says and why, and links to the official text.

APSAC's position in one sentence

APSAC calls for the elimination of all forms of corporal punishment and physical discipline of children, in all environments, including schools and homes. The statement was approved on July 26, 2016, and is listed on APSAC's position statements page.

What counts as corporal punishment

The statement adopts a definition from the research literature: the use of physical force intended to make a child experience pain, but not injury, in order to correct or control the child's behavior. It notes that this covers the many everyday words people use for hitting children as discipline — spanking, swatting, whipping, popping, smacking, slapping and paddling among them. In other words, the position is not limited to extreme or injurious violence; it addresses the ordinary physical discipline many families consider normal.

Why APSAC takes this position

The statement grounds its position in research, citing published studies for each point. In summary, it argues that:

  • Corporal punishment is common in the United States, with research indicating that many children are hit by the time they are toddlers.
  • It increases the risk of physical abuse. The statement cites research — including a large Canadian study — finding that a large share of substantiated physical abuse cases began as corporal punishment, and research showing that young children who are physically punished are at greater risk of child protective services involvement.
  • It is linked to poorer outcomes, including behavior problems such as increased aggression and antisocial behavior.
  • No studies show benefits. According to the statement, research has not shown that corporal punishment has positive effects on children or improves their behavior.
  • The harms appear across cultures. The statement acknowledges that physical discipline is more common and more accepted in some cultural contexts, but notes research associating it with negative outcomes across those contexts.

It also points to a human-rights argument. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, adopted in 1989, calls on governments to protect children from all forms of physical and mental violence. The statement observes that hitting an adult — a spouse, an acquaintance, a stranger — is treated as assault, and argues that children deserve the same protection.

International and professional context

At the time it was written, the statement noted that dozens of countries had banned all corporal punishment of children, including at home, and that many more had committed to doing so; it refers readers to the Global Partnership to End Violence Against Children's tracking work for current figures. It lists other professional bodies whose statements against corporal punishment or in favor of better alternatives informed its own, including the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry's maltreatment and violence committee, the National Association of Pediatric Nurse Practitioners, and Save the Children. It also cites the CDC's technical package on preventing child abuse and neglect, which identifies legislative bans on corporal punishment as one approach to changing social norms in support of positive parenting.

What APSAC asks professionals to do

The statement recommends that professionals who work with children and families:

  1. inform parents, caregivers, teachers and the public about the harmful effects of corporal punishment;
  2. educate parents, caregivers and teachers about age-specific expectations for children's skills, behavior and development; and
  3. offer positive alternatives — non-physical forms of guidance such as teaching limit setting, self-regulation, and respect for self and others.

It describes the goal as nurturing, teaching and guiding children in ways that support their dignity, and pledges that APSAC will help inform allied professionals, policymakers and the public about the risks.

After 2016: support for the AAP's policy

When the American Academy of Pediatrics updated its own guidance in 2018 with the policy statement Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children, APSAC published a statement commending the AAP and urging professionals to put its recommendation into practice. You can read our plain-language summary of the AAP policy.

What this means for families

Professional statements like APSAC's are aimed at the people who advise families, but the message for parents is straightforward: children can be raised to be respectful, responsible and kind without being hit, and there are well-studied ways to do it. Practical help is available in our guides:

In Hampton Roads, Virginia, the same body of research informed the No Hit Zone initiative, which encouraged hospitals and other public places to adopt a simple norm: no adult hitting a child, no adult hitting another adult, and no child hitting an adult or another child.

Sources

  1. American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children. APSAC Position Statement on Corporal Punishment of Children (approved July 26, 2016) (2016).
  2. American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children. Position Statements (n.d.).
  3. American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children. APSAC Statement Supporting American Academy of Pediatrics Policy Calling for an End to Spanking as a Form of Discipline (n.d.).
  4. American Academy of Pediatrics. Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children. Pediatrics 142(6):e20183112 (December 2018).

About this information: This article is general educational information, not medical, psychological or legal advice, and is not a substitute for care from a qualified professional who knows your family. If you are worried about a child's safety, contact your local child protective services agency or, in an emergency, call 911. See our editorial policy for how articles are researched.