Is a child in immediate danger? Call 911.Find help & reporting lines →
Positive Parenting

Positive Discipline: What Parents Can Do Instead of Spanking

Key takeaways

  • The American Academy of Pediatrics advises parents not to spank, hit, yell at or shame children; these methods work poorly over time and are linked to worse outcomes.
  • Discipline means teaching. The most effective tools are attention and specific praise for good behavior, clear limits and predictable follow-through.
  • Consequences work best when they are calm, immediate, brief and related to the misbehavior.
  • Strategies change with age: redirection and time-out for little ones, problem-solving and earned privileges for older kids.
  • If you feel close to losing control, make sure your child is safe and take your own break first.

Many of today's parents were spanked as children, and in a tense moment a swat can feel like the fastest way to stop a behavior. But pediatricians now advise against spanking and other physical punishment, because it does little to teach children how to behave and can carry lasting costs. This guide explains why, then walks through practical, age-by-age discipline tools that help children learn self-control while keeping your relationship strong.

Why pediatricians discourage spanking

In 2018 the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) published a policy statement, Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children, written by Drs. Robert Sege and Benjamin Siegel. It concludes that harsh discipline, including every form of corporal punishment as well as yelling at or shaming children, is only minimally effective in the short term and is not effective in the long term. The statement also notes that newer research links corporal punishment to a higher risk of negative behavioral, cognitive, psychosocial and emotional outcomes, and it calls on adults to avoid both physical punishment and verbal abuse of children. For a plain-language walk-through of the statement, see our summary, What the AAP's Policy on Effective Discipline Says.

The AAP's parent site, HealthyChildren.org, spells out some of the reasons in its Where We Stand: Spanking page and its guide to disciplining your child:

  • It can backfire. Physical punishment is associated with more aggression and defiance in children, which can set up a cycle in which more punishment is followed by more misbehavior.
  • It raises the risk of injury, especially for children younger than 18 months.
  • It can strain the parent–child relationship. The AAP notes that repeated physical punishment may increase conflict between parent and child.
  • It is linked with other harms. The AAP points to associations with mental health and cognitive problems, and with higher levels of stress hormones and differences in brain development.

Other professional groups have reached similar conclusions; you can read about one example in our article on APSAC's position statement on corporal punishment.

None of this means parents should be permissive. The goal of discipline is to teach, and children learn best from adults who are calm, consistent and connected to them.

Core principles that work at every age

Before getting into ages and stages, it helps to understand a few ideas that run through almost all of the research-backed guidance from the AAP and the CDC.

Attention is powerful, so aim it at good behavior

Children want their parents' attention, and they will often repeat whatever behavior earns it, positive or negative. The CDC's guidance on praise and rewards recommends specific, "labeled" praise that names the exact behavior you liked. Instead of a general "good job," a parent might say, "You put your shoes by the door without me asking. That really helps." Social rewards such as a high five, a hug (if your child likes touch), or extra time reading together are free and often more motivating than toys or treats. The CDC also cautions never to take back a reward a child has already earned.

Clear, predictable limits

Children cope better when they know the rules and know what will happen if they break them. Keep family rules few, simple and stated in positive terms ("We use gentle hands"), and explain them in words your child can understand.

Calm, related consequences

A consequence is simply what happens right after a behavior. The CDC's tips for responding to behavior describe logical consequences: a brief loss of a privilege that is directly connected to the misbehavior, such as putting away a toy two children are fighting over. Natural consequences are the outcomes that happen on their own, like feeling chilly after refusing a jacket; the AAP notes that, when there is no danger, letting a child experience them can teach the lesson without a lecture. Give an "if–then" warning only when you are prepared to follow through, and then do it calmly every time.

Plan ahead

Many meltdowns are predictable. Hunger, fatigue, transitions and boredom are common triggers. Preparing your child for what to expect, bringing a snack, or leaving the store before naptime can prevent problems you would otherwise have to discipline.

Toddlers (about 1 to 3 years)

Toddlers are driven by curiosity and have very limited impulse control. They are not being "bad" when they grab, climb or throw; they are exploring and testing. Discipline at this age is mostly about safety, structure and teaching.

  • Childproof and redirect. Remove temptations you do not want to fight over and offer a safe alternative: "Blocks are for building, not throwing. Let's throw this soft ball instead."
  • Save "no" for what matters. When "no" is reserved for safety, it carries more weight.
  • Praise and describe. Short, specific praise ("Gentle touch with the kitty!") teaches the behavior you want.
  • Model calm. Toddlers copy what they see. Staying calm when they hit shows them what to do with big feelings.
  • Keep routines steady. Predictable meals, naps and bedtimes reduce the tiredness and hunger that fuel tantrums.

The CDC's Positive Parenting Tips pages are organized by age and pair discipline ideas with what children are learning developmentally. Knowing what is typical for your child's age makes it easier to set expectations they can actually meet.

Preschoolers (about 3 to 5 years)

Preschoolers can understand simple rules and consequences, and they are beginning to manage their emotions with help. This is a good age to introduce structured tools.

Offer limited choices

Two acceptable options give a child a sense of control without a power struggle: "Do you want to brush teeth before or after pajamas?"

Use time-out carefully

The CDC's time-out guide suggests reserving time-out for behavior that is dangerous or harmful, breaks a family rule, or continues after one warning. In brief, the steps are:

  1. Give a calm warning and a few seconds to comply.
  2. If the behavior continues, say briefly why time-out is happening, without arguing or lecturing.
  3. Guide your child to a dull, safe spot near you, away from toys and screens, for about one minute per year of age.
  4. End time-out once your child has been quiet for a few seconds, and restate the expectation.
  5. Look for the next good behavior and praise it warmly.

Time-out works because it briefly removes your attention, so it only works well when the rest of the day is full of positive attention. If your child is overwhelmed or frightened rather than misbehaving, the CDC suggests "time-in": staying close, naming the feeling and helping them calm down. Our guide to emotional regulation skills covers how to teach calming strategies.

Teach words for feelings

For example, a parent might say, "You're really mad that your tower fell. It's okay to be mad. It's not okay to kick the blocks at your sister. You can stomp your feet or squeeze this pillow."

School-age children (about 6 to 9 years)

School-age children can reason, plan and understand cause and effect. Discipline can shift toward responsibility and problem-solving.

  • Problem-solve together. When a pattern keeps repeating, such as homework battles, sit down at a calm time and ask, "What's getting in the way? What could we try?" Write down a plan and revisit it in a week.
  • Link privileges to responsibilities. Screen time after homework, or a later bedtime on weekends after chores, teaches that freedom grows with follow-through.
  • Use logical consequences. If a bike is left in the driveway, it is put away for a day. If a child is unkind during a game, the game ends for now.
  • Hear them out. The AAP encourages letting children finish explaining before you decide what to do. Feeling heard lowers defensiveness.
  • Keep physical punishment off the table. The AAP's age-by-age guidance specifically says never to allow it at this stage.

Tweens (about 10 to 12 years)

Tweens want more independence and are highly sensitive to being treated fairly. Discipline that feels like control tends to provoke resistance; discipline that feels like a partnership tends to work better.

  • Agree on rules in advance. Involve your tween in setting expectations for phones, curfews and chores, along with the consequences for breaking them.
  • Stay calm and brief. Long lectures invite eye-rolling. State the problem, the consequence and the path back to trust.
  • Protect dignity. Correct in private, not in front of friends or siblings. Shaming and sarcasm are among the harsh verbal tactics the AAP advises against.
  • Keep connecting. Daily check-ins, shared meals and time together make your limits easier to accept.

When you lose your cool

Every parent has moments of anger. The AAP suggests that parents give themselves a time-out when they feel out of control: make sure your child is safe, step away, breathe, or call someone. If you do yell or say something you regret, wait until you are calm, apologize, and explain what you will do differently next time. That repair teaches children something valuable about handling mistakes. Our guide on managing parental stress and anger offers a step-by-step pause plan, and How to Respond to Challenging Behavior gives an in-the-moment script.

Frequently asked questions

Isn't an occasional swat harmless?

The AAP's 2018 policy concludes that corporal punishment in any form is not effective in the long run and is associated with a higher risk of negative outcomes, so it recommends against it. Alternatives such as praise, limits and related consequences teach the skills you actually want.

How long should a time-out last?

The CDC and AAP both suggest about one minute per year of age. Shorter, consistent time-outs work better than long ones.

What if positive discipline doesn't seem to work?

New approaches often take a few weeks of consistency, and behavior may get worse briefly before it improves. If problems are frequent, intense or affecting school or friendships, talk with your child's pediatrician, who can check for underlying issues and refer you to a parent-training program or mental health professional.

Sources

  1. American Academy of Pediatrics (Pediatrics, 142(6):e20183112). Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children (Sege RD, Siegel BS; AAP Council on Child Abuse and Neglect; Committee on Psychosocial Aspects of Child and Family Health) (2018).
  2. American Academy of Pediatrics (HealthyChildren.org). What's the Best Way to Discipline My Child? (2018).
  3. American Academy of Pediatrics (HealthyChildren.org). Where We Stand: Spanking (2018).
  4. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Positive Parenting Tips (2026).
  5. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. How to Use Time-Out (Essentials for Parenting Toddlers and Preschoolers) (2026).
  6. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Tips for Using Praise and Rewards (Essentials for Parenting Toddlers and Preschoolers) (2026).
  7. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Tips for Responding to Behavior (Essentials for Parenting Toddlers and Preschoolers) (2026).

About this information: This article is general educational information, not medical, psychological or legal advice, and is not a substitute for care from a qualified professional who knows your family. If you are worried about a child's safety, contact your local child protective services agency or, in an emergency, call 911. See our editorial policy for how articles are researched.