Is a child in immediate danger? Call 911.Find help & reporting lines →
Research & Insights

What the AAP's Policy on Effective Discipline Says

About this page: Many websites linked to a copy of this AAP policy statement that was once hosted at this domain. That copy belonged to the former organization's website and is no longer hosted here. This page summarizes the statement and links to the official version published by the American Academy of Pediatrics.

Key takeaways

  • The policy statement was published in Pediatrics in December 2018 (volume 142, issue 6, e20183112), led by Robert D. Sege and Benjamin S. Siegel.
  • It concludes that harsh discipline, including spanking, yelling and shaming, is minimally effective in the short term and not effective in the long term.
  • It summarizes research linking corporal punishment with more aggression and defiance and with mental health and cognitive problems.
  • It recommends that adults not use corporal punishment or verbal abuse that shames or humiliates, and use positive reinforcement, limits, redirection and clear expectations instead.

In late 2018 the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) published a policy statement titled Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children. It is one of the most widely cited documents on spanking in the United States — newspapers, universities and parenting sites around the world have linked to it. This page explains, in plain language, what the statement says, the evidence it draws on, and what it recommends parents do instead. For the authoritative wording, always read the official version in Pediatrics.

The statement at a glance

TitleEffective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children
PublishedPediatrics, volume 142, number 6, December 2018 (article e20183112)
Lead authorsRobert D. Sege, MD, PhD, and Benjamin S. Siegel, MD
Issued byAAP Council on Child Abuse and Neglect and AAP Committee on Psychosocial Aspects of Child and Family Health
DOI10.1542/peds.2018-3112
What it updatedThe AAP's 1998 clinical report Guidance for Effective Discipline

The statement is written primarily for pediatricians, who are often the professionals parents ask about behavior and discipline. But its conclusions are directly relevant to parents, teachers and anyone else who cares for children. AAP policy statements expire after five years unless they are reaffirmed, revised or retired. The AAP's publication page for this statement notes that it was reaffirmed in June 2024 (checked November 2026), so it remains current AAP policy; the official page always shows its latest status.

The core conclusion

The statement's summary makes three main points:

  • Harsh discipline doesn't work well. Aversive strategies — the statement names all forms of corporal punishment as well as yelling at or shaming children — are described as minimally effective in the short term and not effective in the long term.
  • Newer research links corporal punishment to harm. Researchers have associated it with an increased risk of negative behavioral, cognitive, psychosocial and emotional outcomes for children.
  • Adults should avoid both physical punishment and verbal abuse. The AAP supports positive, development-appropriate discipline strategies instead.

How the statement defines its terms

For its own purposes, the statement defines corporal punishment narrowly as noninjurious, open-handed hitting intended to modify a child's behavior, and it treats spanking as a form of physical punishment. It also quotes the much broader definition used by the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child, which covers any punishment using physical force intended to cause some pain or discomfort, "however light," as well as cruel or degrading non-physical punishment such as belittling, threatening or ridiculing a child. The statement uses "verbal abuse" for those non-physical forms.

The narrow definition matters: the conclusions are not only about severe beatings. They apply to the ordinary "swat" or spanking many parents think of as harmless.

What evidence the statement summarizes

Spanking is not effective over time

The statement cites a 2016 meta-analysis concluding that the research literature does not support a long-term benefit from physical punishment. It describes a small study using home audio recordings in which, when children were physically punished, most resumed the same behavior within about ten minutes — and in which punishment often followed a parent's first verbal attempt by around half a minute, suggesting parents were frequently reacting emotionally rather than deliberately.

A cycle of spanking and misbehavior

Drawing on the long-running Fragile Families and Child Wellbeing Study, which followed a large birth cohort from 20 US cities, the statement reports that children spanked more than twice a month at age 3 were more aggressive at age 5, even after accounting for their earlier behavior and family factors. Later analyses linked spanking at age 5 with more behavior problems and lower vocabulary scores at age 9, and described a spiral in which more spanking predicted more misbehavior, which in turn prompted more spanking.

Outcomes associated with corporal punishment

The statement lists consequences associated with parental corporal punishment, including:

  • a higher likelihood of physical injury when children younger than 18 months are hit;
  • more aggressive behavior and conflict between parent and child, with possible harm to the relationship;
  • increased aggression in preschool and school-aged children, and a greater (not lesser) likelihood of future defiance;
  • an increased risk of mental health disorders and cognition problems; and
  • outcomes for spanking alone that resemble those seen in children who experience physical abuse.

It also notes that the risk of harsh punishment rises when families are under stress — for example from economic hardship, mental health problems, intimate partner violence or substance use — and that parental depression was linked with more negative views of a child's behavior and more frequent physical punishment.

Effects on stress and the brain

The statement describes small brain-imaging studies of young adults that found differences in brain structure among those exposed to repeated harsh corporal punishment or to parental verbal abuse, and a review linking physical punishment with stress-hormone (cortisol) levels. These are associations from limited samples, and the statement presents them as part of a broader picture rather than as proof on their own.

Harsh words matter too

Citing a longitudinal study of adolescents, the statement reports that harsh verbal discipline before age 13 was associated with increases in conduct problems and depressive symptoms in early adolescence — and that parental warmth did not cancel out that association.

Changing attitudes

The statement presents survey evidence that support for spanking in the United States has been declining, particularly among younger parents, and that pediatricians themselves overwhelmingly do not endorse it: in a 2016 survey it cites, only a small minority of responding US pediatricians held positive attitudes toward spanking. It also observes that many parents describe spanking as a last resort — which is why the AAP emphasizes giving parents other tools.

What the AAP recommends

The statement's policy recommendations can be summarized as follows:

  1. No corporal punishment and no shaming. Parents, caregivers and other adults should not use corporal punishment — including hitting and spanking — whether in anger or as a planned consequence, and should not use any strategy, including verbal abuse, that causes shame or humiliation.
  2. Pediatricians can help. When advising families, pediatricians may offer guidance on effective discipline, information about the risks and ineffectiveness of corporal punishment, and the perspective that although many children who were spanked grow into healthy adults, current evidence suggests spanking is unnecessary and may cause long-term harm.
  3. Family-support agencies should share alternatives. Family resource centers, schools and public health agencies are encouraged to give families information about effective alternatives.
  4. Advocacy. Pediatricians are encouraged to support this policy at local and state levels.

In its conclusions, the AAP recommends healthy forms of discipline such as positive reinforcement of appropriate behavior, setting limits, redirecting, and setting future expectations, and recommends that parents not use spanking, hitting, slapping, threatening, insulting, humiliating or shaming.

What this means for parents

The statement does not ask parents to stop disciplining their children. It asks them to discipline in ways that teach. The word "discipline," it points out, comes from a Latin root meaning to teach or train. In practice that looks like:

  • noticing and praising the behavior you want to see — the statement gives the example of a simple "I love it when you…";
  • setting clear, age-appropriate limits and following through calmly;
  • using redirection, time-outs and logical consequences instead of hitting;
  • planning ahead for situations that usually go badly; and
  • getting support — from your pediatrician, a parenting program or a family resource center — if you find yourself relying on spanking or yelling.

Our guides Positive Discipline: What Parents Can Do Instead of Spanking and How to Respond to Challenging Behavior Without Physical Punishment turn these principles into step-by-step strategies, and How Parents Can Manage Stress and Anger covers what to do when you feel close to losing control.

Parenting programs the statement mentions

The statement points to several kinds of support that can help families replace physical punishment, including the AAP's HealthyChildren.org website and its Connected Kids and Bright Futures materials, the CDC's positive parenting tips, and evidence-based or structured programs such as Triple P, HealthySteps, the Safe Environment for Every Kid (SEEK) model, The Incredible Years and the Chicago Parent Program. It notes that its list is not comprehensive and that many communities offer effective local parenting resources. For help finding support, see When and How to Seek Family Support.

The AAP is not alone. The American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children (APSAC) issued its own position statement calling for an end to corporal punishment in 2016 and later published a statement supporting the AAP's 2018 policy. Read our summary of APSAC's position statement on corporal punishment. In Hampton Roads, Virginia, these ideas were also behind the No Hit Zone initiative, which encouraged hospitals and other public places to adopt "no hitting" norms.

Sources

  1. American Academy of Pediatrics. Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children (Sege RD, Siegel BS; AAP Council on Child Abuse and Neglect; AAP Committee on Psychosocial Aspects of Child and Family Health). Pediatrics 142(6):e20183112. doi:10.1542/peds.2018-3112 (December 2018).
  2. American Academy of Pediatrics (HealthyChildren.org). Where We Stand: Spanking (2018).
  3. American Academy of Pediatrics (HealthyChildren.org). What's the Best Way to Discipline My Child? (2018).
  4. American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children. APSAC Statement Supporting American Academy of Pediatrics Policy Calling for an End to Spanking as a Form of Discipline (n.d.).

About this information: This article is general educational information, not medical, psychological or legal advice, and is not a substitute for care from a qualified professional who knows your family. If you are worried about a child's safety, contact your local child protective services agency or, in an emergency, call 911. See our editorial policy for how articles are researched.