Is a child in immediate danger? Call 911.Find help & reporting lines →
Research & Insights

Spanking and Child Outcomes: What a Major 2016 Meta-Analysis Found

Key takeaways

  • Elizabeth Gershoff and Andrew Grogan-Kaylor's meta-analyses, published in the Journal of Family Psychology in 2016, focused specifically on spanking rather than harsher physical punishment.
  • They pooled 111 effect sizes representing about 160,000 children.
  • Spanking was significantly associated with 13 of the 17 outcomes examined, and every significant association pointed to more harm, not benefit.
  • Associations for spanking were similar in direction to those for physical abuse, and held across different study designs.
  • The findings are associations from observational studies; they were influential in later guidance such as the AAP's 2018 policy statement.

Few parenting questions have been studied as much as spanking. Hundreds of studies have looked at how physical punishment relates to children's behavior, mental health and development — and for years, reviews of that research reached different conclusions. In 2016, researchers Elizabeth Gershoff (University of Texas at Austin) and Andrew Grogan-Kaylor (University of Michigan) published a set of meta-analyses designed to settle two of the most persistent objections. This page explains what they did, what they found, and what the findings do and don't mean.

The study at a glance

TitleSpanking and Child Outcomes: Old Controversies and New Meta-Analyses
AuthorsElizabeth T. Gershoff and Andrew Grogan-Kaylor
JournalJournal of Family Psychology, 2016, volume 30, issue 4, pages 453–469
DOI10.1037/fam0000191
Data pooled111 unique effect sizes representing 160,927 children

What a meta-analysis is

A meta-analysis combines the results of many separate studies using statistical methods, producing an overall estimate of how strongly two things are related. Because it pools large numbers of children from many samples, it can reveal consistent patterns that single studies might miss — though it is only as good as the studies it includes.

The two controversies it addressed

Earlier meta-analyses had disagreed. Some concluded that physical punishment was largely ineffective and harmful; others concluded it could be effective in some circumstances or that its links to problems were modest. Critics raised two recurring objections:

  1. Mixing spanking with abuse. Some argued that earlier reviews lumped ordinary spanking together with harsher punishment that crosses into abuse, inflating the apparent harm.
  2. Study design. Others argued that weaker study designs might exaggerate the association.

Gershoff and Grogan-Kaylor responded by analyzing studies that focused specifically on spanking — defined as hitting a child on the buttocks or extremities with an open hand — and by testing whether results differed by study design.

What they found

Spanking was linked with worse outcomes

Thirteen of the 17 mean effect sizes were statistically significant, and all 13 indicated that spanking was associated with an increased risk of detrimental outcomes. None of the significant associations showed spanking linked to better outcomes.

In childhood, spanking was associated with:

  • more aggression, antisocial behavior and externalizing behavior problems;
  • more internalizing problems and mental health problems;
  • lower moral internalization (taking parents' values as one's own);
  • more negative parent–child relationships;
  • lower cognitive ability and lower self-esteem; and
  • greater risk of physical abuse from parents.

In adulthood, people who had been spanked as children were more likely to show antisocial behavior and mental health problems, and to hold positive attitudes about spanking. The four remaining outcomes were not significantly different from zero.

Spanking looked similar to physical abuse

The authors compared effect sizes for spanking with those for physical abuse and found they did not substantially differ — the associations ran in the same direction and were of similar size. In other words, removing harsher punishment from the analysis did not make spanking look harmless.

Results held across study designs

The associations did not substantially differ by study design characteristics, which addressed the concern that weaker studies were driving the results.

What the findings don't prove

The studies pooled here are largely observational: researchers measured spanking and outcomes rather than randomly assigning families to spank or not, which would be unethical. That means the results show consistent associations, not proof that spanking causes each outcome in every child. Many children who were spanked grow into healthy adults — a point the American Academy of Pediatrics also makes — but the weight of evidence suggests spanking is unnecessary and carries risk without benefit.

How the research has been used

This work became one of the most widely cited pieces of evidence on physical punishment. The American Academy of Pediatrics' 2018 policy statement cites a 2016 meta-analysis in concluding that the literature does not support a long-term benefit from physical punishment — read our summary of the AAP policy. Gershoff also visited Hampton Roads, Virginia in January 2017 to share her research with local advocates involved in the No Hit Zone initiative.

What it means for parents

If you were spanked, or have spanked your own children, this research is not a judgment of you — it is information. The practical takeaway is that there are better tools: attention and praise for good behavior, clear limits, calm consequences and problem-solving. Start with Positive Discipline: What Parents Can Do Instead of Spanking and How to Respond to Challenging Behavior Without Physical Punishment.

Sources

  1. American Psychological Association. Spanking and Child Outcomes: Old Controversies and New Meta-Analyses (Gershoff ET, Grogan-Kaylor A). Journal of Family Psychology 30(4):453–469. doi:10.1037/fam0000191 (2016).
  2. American Academy of Pediatrics. Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children. Pediatrics 142(6):e20183112 (December 2018).
  3. American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children. APSAC Position Statement on Corporal Punishment of Children (2016).

About this information: This article is general educational information, not medical, psychological or legal advice, and is not a substitute for care from a qualified professional who knows your family. If you are worried about a child's safety, contact your local child protective services agency or, in an emergency, call 911. See our editorial policy for how articles are researched.